patching...
Breaking: Fire Ignites at Pinebrook Road Home Wednesday Morning »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Reward and Punishment, Good Idea or Bad?

A common, yet misconstrued belief among some teachers and parents is that the act of rewarding or punishing a student based on educational performance is a key motivational tool inside and outside the classroom. However, studies show that students who are lured into doing something for a reward are less likely to do it again if no reward is offered.

Moreover, such research also proves that punishment can often evoke a feeling of defiance and anger in children.  The once popular conception of reward and punishment is being overshadowed by the proof that such actions could produce an inverse, or opposite, effect.

In addition, some psychologists believe that the most effective type of reward is giving praise. Praise and positive reinforcement that is directed towards a specific assignment or task assists the student in evaluating themselves. Receiving praise and positive feedback emphasizes that success is directly related to the amount of effort the student puts into their work.  Praise is a tool that is helpful for the student to assess themselves and help them set educational goals.

Ultimately, students will become more independent learners if their motivation is not reliant on punishment and rewards, but rather on the praise that results from a job well done. This concept will reveal to students that the amount of effort they put into their work and educational success are directly related.

Fred Gee

6:17 pm on Thursday, January 5, 2012

Praise/Admonishment = Reward/Punishment

Reply

S Talarico

5:53 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012

Positive reinforcement is a good way to train husbands, too! :)

Reply
Comment_arrow

fed up

9:46 pm on Sunday, February 10, 2013

Yes, it also works great with dogs. But children? How about doing it the way it was done for hundreds if not thousands of years. Pay attention in class listen to your teacher and do your homework. And if you fail you are punished period end of story. This is just another example of the dummy down, don't hurt their feelings,pussification of our children these days. Who cares if the kids get angry when punished? Then wise up.

Ralph Splendorio

7:21 pm on Saturday, January 14, 2012

It depends on what you consider punishment. There also needs to be negative ramifications to negative behavior. If you do not study for a test and fail it.... that is not punishment but rather the direct negative ramification of the actions of the student. Punishment cannot be punitive but negative ramifications (that most students will see as punishment thought they are net) I believe are essential to the learning process.

Reply

Lila

5:24 pm on Sunday, February 10, 2013

I believe we should use our successes and failures as information, not reward and punishment. It's like what Einstein said "everybody is a genius, but if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that t is stupid"

Reply

Leave a comment

The Manalapan Patch
Valentine's Shopping Guide

See the full guide!

Patch Picks