A System on Trial?

Mercy Killer in Ohio

In Akron, OH, continues the remarkable and disturbing murder prosecution of Mr. John Wise.  Last year, Mr. Wise walked into his wife’s hospital room and killed her with a shotgun.  The District Attorney has accused him of aggravated murder, murder and felonious assault, while his defense has labeled the act a “mercy killing.”  For many, these events put the legal system itself on trial, as it tries to decide whether intense emotional duress can be the basis for an insanity plea. For patients and families overwhelmed by the burden of terminal disease, perhaps what should actually be judged is not the courts, but the medical system. 

Barbara and John Wise were married for 45 years, and by available accounts had a close and supportive relationship.  John suffers from diabetes, has a history of bladder cancer in remission, and is plagued by a peripheral neuropathy that makes his hands and feet numb.  Barbara, 65, was relatively healthy until she suffered a massive stroke that left her immobile and unable to speak.  According to Wise’s attorney, and also a former co-worker, the couple had agreed they never wished to be disabled or in a nursing home. 

On July 28, 2012, one week after the stroke, John shot his wife, one time, and she died 24 hours later. Reportedly, he did not threaten hospital staff and was immediately disarmed and restrained by security.  After arraignment, he was released to his home with an ankle monitor.  Motions are presently being heard and his trial, if it occurs, will not be until at least spring.  Given the history of similar events, likely a plea bargain will be reached. 

As our population ages and more elderly patients and couples experience acute and chronic disease, experts believe similar events are likely to occur with rising frequency.  The stress that results in such horrible desperation is overwhelmingly destructive and represents a failure of doctors and healthcare workers to give support, guidance and present alternatives.  Taking these events at face value, one can only begin to comprehend the depth of pain that John must have felt when he entered Barbara’s room.  If we are going to address such critical needs in medicine, being ready to intervene at these common, if extreme times, must be a core mission.

There are several parts of “the system” which can help.  First, physicians must recognize the pain induced by acute and chronic health stress, and reach out, respond, discussing choices, such as social work, acute grief counseling and referral to palliative care.  Other contacts in the health system, be they emergency room staff, nurses, extended care facilities or pharmacists, must recognize their role to educate, and support.  At times “ancillary” professions, which we may not always view as gateways to healthcare, such as funeral home directors or estate attorneys, may be vital links.

Improving access to end-of-life services through hospice, can provide compassionate choice, ease stress and help shoulder emotional burdens.  Families should be educated that supports are available not only in the hospital, but in their homes, senior centers and extended care facilities. Some will propose this is a role for assisted suicide, but given the overwhelming and erratic emotions that are in play in these situations, our primary intervention should be to supply support and stability, and not potentiate extreme decisions with the potential for disruptive long-term guilt.

A civilized nation should be judged by how it treats and helps those in greatest need.  Clearly, those persons suddenly cast into hell by disease, those with limited supports, those with limited apparent alternatives, demonstrate great need. Given the likelihood that such highly traumatic medical events will increase, there is a role for all of us to open up our minds, eyes and hearts.


As published in Sunrise Rounds.


By using this blog, you agree to these terms, which may change. This blog is for personal educational use only. Children under the age of 13 may not use this blog. Blog user agrees not to rely on this blog and releases Blogger from any damages arising from its use. This blog is compliant with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. Please report infringements to jimsal@sunriserounds.com.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »