Barbara's Cookie Pies 22 Kensington Dr, Manalapan, NJ07726 Barbara's Cookie Pies is a local commercial bakery that specializes in fresh hand-made cookie pies available for…More purchase on the company's website. True to its name, cookie pies are a blend of the two desserts. They look like pies, but can be conveniently eaten like cookies. They come in an array of flavors, including rocky road, apple caramel, key lime macadamia, double cranberry, peanut butter cup and more. In addition the bakery also offers a selection of butter cookies, seasonal cookie pies and kits for making your own cookie pies.